Difference between revisions of "Talk:Large Laser Cutter Vote"

From Pumping Station One
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "This is the second vote-in-progress proposing a fundraising campaign with kickstarter-style rewards. Who is expected to fulfill these rewards? Just laying this at the feet of...")
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 
This is the second vote-in-progress proposing a fundraising campaign with kickstarter-style rewards. Who is expected to fulfill these rewards? Just laying this at the feet of the board without specifying a person or persons committed to making sure things get done seems presumptuous. Running a crowdfunding campaign is a lot of work, and voting to put that responsibility on the board seems like a bad idea to me. --[[User:Dbever|Dbever]] ([[User talk:Dbever|talk]]) 09:18, 3 March 2016 (CST)
 
This is the second vote-in-progress proposing a fundraising campaign with kickstarter-style rewards. Who is expected to fulfill these rewards? Just laying this at the feet of the board without specifying a person or persons committed to making sure things get done seems presumptuous. Running a crowdfunding campaign is a lot of work, and voting to put that responsibility on the board seems like a bad idea to me. --[[User:Dbever|Dbever]] ([[User talk:Dbever|talk]]) 09:18, 3 March 2016 (CST)
 +
 +
==What kind of laser to buy?==
 +
 +
This is an area open for debate. Personally, I'd like to see a laser with a 4' wide bed, full feed through (e.g. you can laser a 4x8 sheet of lumber in segments), and a lot more power (100+ watts) to cut thicker material. Doing that at a reasonable cost likely means going with a Chinese laser. I know some people don't like Chinese lasers and want to go with something that has US support (like Universal Laser Systems, Trotec, etc.) that may also be more user friendly, but those either cost a lot more money or don't provide all that much improvement over the Epilog. Some wanted to get a Kern with oxygen assist that can cut sheet metal, although it is unlikely with renting the space next door that we can afford that now, and a CNC plasma cutter can probably handle cutting metal better. But the bottom line is that these are controversial issues and the vote doesn't provide specs. We've had more than enough money for a new laser for some time, and I think everyone sees the priority in getting one. I think the reason why we don't have one yet is that the membership couldn't decide which one to buy. This vote doesn't address that issue. --[[User:Rdpierce|Rdpierce]] ([[User talk:Rdpierce|talk]]) 07:34, 9 March 2016 (CST)

Revision as of 13:34, 9 March 2016

This is the second vote-in-progress proposing a fundraising campaign with kickstarter-style rewards. Who is expected to fulfill these rewards? Just laying this at the feet of the board without specifying a person or persons committed to making sure things get done seems presumptuous. Running a crowdfunding campaign is a lot of work, and voting to put that responsibility on the board seems like a bad idea to me. --Dbever (talk) 09:18, 3 March 2016 (CST)

What kind of laser to buy?

This is an area open for debate. Personally, I'd like to see a laser with a 4' wide bed, full feed through (e.g. you can laser a 4x8 sheet of lumber in segments), and a lot more power (100+ watts) to cut thicker material. Doing that at a reasonable cost likely means going with a Chinese laser. I know some people don't like Chinese lasers and want to go with something that has US support (like Universal Laser Systems, Trotec, etc.) that may also be more user friendly, but those either cost a lot more money or don't provide all that much improvement over the Epilog. Some wanted to get a Kern with oxygen assist that can cut sheet metal, although it is unlikely with renting the space next door that we can afford that now, and a CNC plasma cutter can probably handle cutting metal better. But the bottom line is that these are controversial issues and the vote doesn't provide specs. We've had more than enough money for a new laser for some time, and I think everyone sees the priority in getting one. I think the reason why we don't have one yet is that the membership couldn't decide which one to buy. This vote doesn't address that issue. --Rdpierce (talk) 07:34, 9 March 2016 (CST)