1,183
edits
Changes
From Pumping Station One
→This proposal ends up giving the Board new powers
:::Justin, that logic is contradictory. You assert that this policy proposal does not make any change to the Bylaws, nor does it overrule the Bylaws. The Bylaws give the Board the power "to decide on issues" "to fulfill any obligations to ensure the health of the organization". That is the grounds under which the Board created the three insurance-related policies that it did. If it is true that this policy proposal is not changing the Bylaws or overruling them, then it follows that the policy proposal cannot remove any powers from the Board that the Bylaws grants. --[[User:Rdpierce|Rdpierce]] ([[User talk:Rdpierce|talk]]) 00:12, 6 May 2015 (CDT)
:::Justin, that logic is contradictory. You assert that this policy proposal does not make any change to the Bylaws, nor does it overrule the Bylaws. The Bylaws give the Board the power "to decide on issues" "to fulfill any obligations to ensure the health of the organization". That is the grounds under which the Board created the three insurance-related policies that it did. If it is true that this policy proposal is not changing the Bylaws or overruling them, then it follows that the policy proposal cannot remove any powers from the Board that the Bylaws grants. --[[User:Rdpierce|Rdpierce]] ([[User talk:Rdpierce|talk]]) 00:12, 6 May 2015 (CDT)
::::Ryan, you're nitpicking my statement instead of responding to it in full. My point was that this vote does not change what issues are proper for a vote of the directors (which is why I linked to that section). Please try to keep the discussion about the actual issue at hand instead of just arguing semantics about my comments. For the record, I'm still of the opinion that the board overreached their authority when creating those policies. --[[User:Justin|Justin]] ([[User talk:Justin|talk]]) 12:49, 6 May 2015 (CDT)
== Automatic extension and rigid timeline prevents further editing ==
== Automatic extension and rigid timeline prevents further editing ==
